To offset the fact that the statistical power of the heterogeneity test may be low, we tested the. The key difference between crystalloids and colloids is that the colloids contain much larger molecules than that of crystalloids crystalloid and colloid solutions are largely useful for medical purposes. They were also crystalloid or colloid for fluid resuscitation in paediatrics. Colloid solutions are widely used in fluid resuscitation of critically ill patients.
Longterm impact of crystalloid versus colloid solutions. Consensus statement by the esicm and cochrane umbrella. Results for crystalloids and colloids 1 50 of 149 sorted by relevance date click export csv or ris to download the entire page or use the checkboxes to select a subset of records to download. Dennis p phillips 0 1 2 a murat kaynar 0 1 2 john a kellum 0 1 hernando gomez 0 1. In an accompanying editorial, seymour and angus discuss making a pragmatic choice for fluid resuscitation.
If you do not see its contents the file may be temporarily unavailable at the journal website or you do not have a pdf plugin installed and enabled in your browser. Roberts i, alderson p, bunn f, chinnock p, ker k, schierhout g. Mortality from all causes at end of follow up for each trial. Gelofusine is a type of colloid fluid that cannot be used among patients. Morbidity and mortality of crystalloids compared to. Cook coauthored a previous metaanalysis of colloids versus crystalloids. A comparison of albumin and saline for fluid resuscitation in the intensive care. Hypovolaemic shock occurs when there is a reduction of intravascular volume by 15% or more oneill and perrin, 2002. Hes was the only colloid associated with increased mortality vs.
We searched for and gathered data from medline, elsevier, cochrane central register of controlled trials and web of science databases. Scandinavian guidelines recommend crystalloid over colloid, and this reflects the broad trend in critical care over the last 20 years. Choosing between colloids and crystalloids for iv infusion. Pdf to determine the effect on mortality of rescuscitation with colloid solutions compared with resuscitation with crystalloids. Advantages and disadvantages of colloid and crystalloid. Appendix 1 provides the incidence of chronic kidney disease and stages at 12 months in the two groups. Doc coloides vs cristaloides jefferson celi academia. This finding was similar to results from previous large trials comparing a single colloid to a single crystalloid. Fluid resuscitation with colloid and crystalloid solutions is a ubiquitous intervention in acute medicine. It is an intravenous colloid that behaves much like blood filled with albumins. Comparison of crystalloid resuscitation fluids for.
Soluciones cristaloides y coloides mi buen trabajo duration. In icu patients with hypovolemia requiring resuscitation, the use of colloids vs. Coloides versus cristaloides en fluidoterapia guiada por objetivos. Cochrane central register of controlled trials biblioteca cochrane. Brazilian journal of anesthesiology edicion en espanol.
The metaanalysis was performed in line with cochrane collaboration and the quality of reporting of metaanalyses guidelines. Any transmission of this document by any media or format is strictly prohibited. Comparison of the effects of albumin and crystalloid on. Studies were eligible if they compared the effects of albumin versus crystalloid therapy on mortality in adult patients with. Heterogeneity was evaluated with the q cochrane statistic and the i 2 index, which provides an approximation of the proportion of total variability in point estimates that can be attributed to heterogeneity. Coloides versus cristaloides en fluidoterapia guiada por. Gelofusine is a colloid volume expander which may be used as a blood plasma replacement when a significant amount of blood is lost due to extreme hemorrhagia, trauma, dehydration, or a similar event. Both are suitable in fluid resuscitation, hypovolaemia, trauma, sepsis and. At 1 yr, disability as assessed by the whodas score was statistically significantly lower in the colloid than in the crystalloid group 2. Colloids and crystalloids are types of fluids that are used for fluid replacement, often intravenously via a tube straight into the blood.
Therefore, alternative fluid therapy with colloids such as albumin may be appropriate to restore hemodynamic endpoints in a more timely and effective manner. Both are suitable in fluid resuscitation, hypovolaemia, trauma, sepsis and burns, and in the pre. Embase y cochrane library comprobando ensayos clinicos aleatorizados. Crystalloid resuscitation is associated with a lower mortality in trauma patients. Crystalloids and colloids are plasma volume expanders used to increase a depleted circulating volume. Pdf fluid resuscitation with colloid or crystalloid. A number of crystalloids and colloids synthetic and. Key controversies in colloid and crystalloid fluid utilization. The crystalloidcolloid fluid therapy debate in dogs and cats. Overall, there is no apparent difference in pulmonary edema, mortality, or length of stay between isotonic crystalloid and colloid resuscitation. Colloids versus crystalloids for fluid resuscitation in. There is insufficient evidence to support the preferential use of colloids or crystalloids in paediatric sepsis.
Dissimilarly, there is remarkably little research related to the study of these fluids for the treatment of acute brain injury. Objective to compare the haemodynamic effect of crystalloids and colloids during acute severe hypovolaemic shock. Haemodynamic response to crystalloids or colloids in shock. We searched the cochrane hepatobiliary group controlled. Accordingly, colloids appear to confer, at best, a small bene. Setting cristal was conducted in intensive care units in. The colloids versus crystalloids for the resuscitation of the critically ill cristal trial was designed to test the hypothesis that colloids altered 28day mortality compared with crystalloids for fluid resuscitation in a general population of critically ill patients. Cristaloides e coloides na pratica clinica proqualis. The 10 trials that compared colloid in hypertonic crystalloid with isotonic crystalloid n1422 and one trial that compared colloid in isotonic crystalloid with hypertonic crystalloid n38 are described in the longer version on our website. Crystalloids fluids such as normal saline typically have a balanced electrolyte composition and expand total extracellular volume. There are several choices of colloid and there is ongoing debate about the relative effectiveness of colloids compared to crystalloid fluids.
Plasma volume expanders crystalloid, colloid or a mixture of both are used to restore vascular volume, stabilise circulatory haemodynamics and maintain tissue perfusion oneill, 2001. Annane and coauthors report the results of the cristal pragmatic randomized trial on the effects of fluid resuscitation with colloids vs crystalloids on mortality in critically ill patients. A bibliographic research was carried out in medline pubmed, embase and cochrane. Guyatts expenses to attend a conference and provided an honorarium that he contributed to a mcmaster university research fund. To assess the effects of colloids compared to crystalloids for fluid resuscitation in critically ill patients. Large number of the studies 50% conducted prior to 1990 few trails were blinded, heterogeneous none of the meta analyses supported the conclusion that choice of resuscitation fluid was critical for. In summary, crystalloid is currently in, and colloid is out. Difference between crystalloids and colloids compare the. Colloids versus crystalloids in objectiveguided fluid.
The aim of this study was to examine whether albumin reduced mortality when employed for the resuscitation of adult patients with severe sepsis and septic shock compared with crystalloid by metaanalysis. Colloids no clear benefit of colloids expensive over crystalloids inexpensive overall show increased mortality in patients with traumatic brain injury tbi no indications currently exist for the use of colloids over crystalloids albumin no unique benefit as a. Colloids vs crystalloid critics to schierhout, cochrane, and choi. Colloids are increasingly used but they are more expensive than crystalloids. Hence, it is vital to know the difference between crystalloids and colloids so as to decide when to use these solutions. Fluid resuscitation with colloid or crystalloid solutions. Cook and guyatt have received no personal funding from pharmaceutical agencies producing either colloids or crystalloids. Methodological limitations preclude any evidencebased clinical recommendations. Design exploratory subgroup analysis of a multicentre randomised controlled trial colloids versus crystalloids for the resuscitation of the critically ill, cristal, clinicaltrials. In the saline versus albumin fluid evaluation safe and albumin italian outcome sepsis albios trials, the ratios of crystalloid to albumin required for resuscitation were 1. Fluid resuscitation is essential for the survival of critically ill patients in shock, regardless of the origin of shock. Colloid solutions broadly partitioned into synthetic fluids such as hetastarch and natural such as albumin exert a high oncotic pressure and thus expand volume via oncotic drag.
62 967 891 1235 1047 1552 823 91 873 1043 1590 81 830 1406 660 1489 1269 1362 6 626 1065 315 1218 558 635 276 468 1074 68